GenetixBayEST. 2009
Quick answer · Systems · How-to

Should I top off my reservoir with plain water or nutrient solution?

Grower practice
Draft: awaiting expert review Updated
  • Also asked
  • Should I top off with plain water?
  • How do I top up my DWC reservoir?
  • What EC should my reservoir top-off be?
  • Top off with nutrients or just water?
  • Why does my reservoir EC go up when the water level drops?

Short answer

Top off a hydro reservoir according to what its EC did since the last check. EC up: plain, pH-adjusted water. EC steady: solution at the reservoir's current EC. EC down: solution at full target strength. With no meter, plain or quarter-strength water is the safe default, and a full refresh every 7–14 days resets everything. Grower practice, built on basic uptake chemistry.

Why

Plants absorb water and nutrient ions at different ratios, and the ratio changes with stage, light and humidity [1]. When they drink more water than salts, the solution concentrates and EC rises. When they take more salts than water, EC falls.

A fixed-strength top-off ignores which is happening: full strength on a rising EC builds salts; plain water on a falling EC starves the plant.

EC is a total, not a recipe. Each element is taken up at its own rate, so the ion balance drifts even when EC reads correctly. That is why closed systems still need periodic full changes [2].

Fresh top-off water should be at reservoir temperature, 18–22 °C (64–72 °F). Warm top-ups raise root-rot risk [3].

The numbers

EC change since last check Top off with pH
Rising (+0.2 mS/cm or more) Plain water 5.6–6.0
Steady (±0.1 mS/cm) Solution at current reservoir EC 5.6–6.0
Falling (−0.2 mS/cm or more) Solution at full target EC 5.6–6.0
No meter Plain or quarter-strength 5.6–6.0
Full change Every 7–14 days 5.6–6.0

DWC EC targets: 0.6–1.0 mS/cm seedling, 1.0–1.6 veg, 1.4–2.0 flower (ppm500 = EC × 500; ppm700 = EC × 700).

What to do

  1. Mark the full line and log EC and pH daily.
  2. Before topping off, compare EC with yesterday's reading.
  3. Mix the top-off to match the table, at reservoir temperature.
  4. Re-check pH after topping off; adjust within 5.6–6.0. Wear gloves and eye protection with pH-down acid.
  5. Change the whole reservoir every 7–14 days.

Common mistakes

  • Topping off with full-strength nutrients every time, so EC climbs all week.
  • Top-off water much colder or warmer than the reservoir.
  • Skipping full changes because the EC "looks fine".

Follow-up questions

Why does my reservoir EC rise as the water drops?

Reservoir EC rises as the level drops because the plants are drinking water faster than they take up nutrient ions, so the salts left behind become more concentrated. This is common in warm, dry rooms with high transpiration. Top off with plain, pH-adjusted water to bring EC back down, and consider lowering the strength of your next fresh batch a little.

Why does my reservoir EC keep dropping?

Reservoir EC drops when the plants take up nutrients faster than water, which usually means they are hungry and the solution is weaker than they want. It is common in mid flower and in cool, humid rooms. Top off with solution at your full target EC, and raise the strength of the next fresh batch by about 0.1–0.2 mS/cm if it keeps happening.

How often should I change the reservoir if I top it off?

Change a hydro reservoir completely every 7–14 days even if you top it off between changes. Topping off corrects volume and EC, but the plants take up each element at a different rate, so the balance of ions drifts away from the recipe over time even when the EC reading looks right. A common rule is to change sooner once you have topped off about one reservoir's worth.

Sources

  1. Sonneveld C, Voogt W. 2009. Plant Nutrition of Greenhouse Crops. Springer. doi.org/10.1007/978-90-481-2532-6
  2. Resh HM, 2022. Hydroponic Food Production, 8th ed. CRC Press (closed vs open systems). doi.org/10.1201/9781003133254
  3. Colorado State University Extension PlantTalk 2043. Root disease problems and management in hydroponic systems (68–72 °F). planttalk.colostate.edu/topics/miscellaneous/2043-root-disea

Related quick answers

← All quick answers

Professor Greenleaf

Grow with the Professor.

The GenetixBay community is coming: honest grow journals, permanent GB-IDs for genetics, and a Professor who answers with citations. Founding Members get first access and the lowest numbers in the archive.