GenetixBayEST. 2009
Breeding · Intermediate · 3 min read

F1, F2, F3 explained: what filial generations really mean

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

Established
Draft: awaiting expert review Updated
Any stageAny system

Short answer. F1 = parent A x parent B. F2 = F1 x F1 (siblings, in cannabis). F3 = F2 x F2, and so on. The textbook promise ("F1s are uniform") holds only when both parents are inbred. Cross two heterozygous clones, which is what most cannabis "F1s" are, and you get variation from the first generation.

What's happening

The textbook case (inbred parents)

  • P1 is AA BB CC..., P2 is aa bb cc... (both homozygous).
  • F1 is Aa Bb Cc... at every differing gene: genetically identical siblings, uniform, often vigorous (hybrid vigour) [2].
  • F2: each gene segregates 1:2:1, so variation is maximal. With 10 differing genes there are 3^10 = 59,049 genotype combinations [1].
  • F3 and later: with sibling mating and selection, heterozygosity falls and families become more uniform.

The cannabis case (heterozygous parents)

Most elite cannabis clones are highly heterozygous polyhybrids [5]. Crossing two of them is genetically like an F2 at many genes: the "F1" segregates. That's why one pack of "F1 hybrid" seed can show several distinct phenotypes. Calling it F1 is correct by definition (first generation of that cross) but misleading about uniformity.

How fast does heterozygosity fall?

Mating system Heterozygosity left after each generation After 4 generations After 6 generations
Selfing (S1, S2...) x ½ ~6% ~1.6%
Full-sib mating H(t) = ½H(t-1) + ¼H(t-2); tends to x 0.81 per generation ~41% ~27%
Random mating in a large population ~no change

Values are single-locus expectations starting from unrelated parents [2]; selection and linkage change them in practice. The point: sib-mated cannabis lines take many generations to approach true breeding, and "F5 IBL" says more about effort than about measured uniformity.

Worked example: chemotype in F1 and F2

THC-dominant inbred (B_T/B_T) x CBD-dominant inbred (B_D/B_D) [3]:

  • F1: all B_T/B_D, all mixed type II. Uniform for chemotype.
  • F2: 1 type I : 2 type II : 1 type III.
  • F3 from a type III F2 pair: all type III. Fixed for that trait.

Note that being fixed for chemotype says nothing about the other few thousand genes.

Naming conventions

Label Meaning Uniformity to expect
F1 (inbred parents) Uniform hybrid High
F1 (clone x clone) First cross of two heterozygous plants Low to moderate
F2 F1 sibling cross Lowest; best for finding new combinations
F3-F6 Further sib generations with selection Rising
BX1, BX2 Backcrosses to one parent Moving towards the recurrent parent
S1 Selfed Variable; reveals recessives
IBL "Inbred line", undefined generation count Claim; check data

Step by step: making F2s that mean something

  1. Grow out at least 10-20 F1s (both sexes for regular seed).
  2. Select the best female and the best 1-3 males (by progeny tests if you can).
  3. Make the F2 cross and record parents as GB-IND IDs, not just the line name.
  4. Grow a large F2 (see pheno hunting for numbers) and select.
  5. Advance by crossing selected F2 siblings; to stabilise, keep the population from bottlenecking to a single pair every generation (inbreeding depression) [4].

Common mistakes

  • Expecting uniform F1s from two clone-only parents.
  • Selling F2s as if they were stable. They are the opposite.
  • Making every generation from one male and one female. That is close to selfing in its inbreeding effect, without the planning.

Evidence

  • Segregation, F1 uniformity from inbred parents, F2 variability: Established [1][2].
  • Heterozygosity of commercial cannabis: Supported [5].
  • Chemotype example: Established [3].
  • Inbreeding effects of narrow sib-mating: Established in general plant genetics [4].

Questions this article answers

What does F1 mean on a seed pack?

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

Why are my F1 plants not uniform?

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

Why are F2 seeds so variable?

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

How many generations to make a stable strain?

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

Is an F2 the same as an S1?

An F1 is the first generation from two parents; it is uniform only if both parents were true-breeding (inbred). An F2 comes from crossing F1 siblings and shows the most variation. Each later generation of sib-mating with selection increases uniformity slowly. In cannabis, most 'F1 hybrids' are crosses of heterozygous clones, so they behave like segregating F2s.

Sources

  1. Miko I. 2008. Gregor Mendel and the principles of inheritance. Nature Education 1(1):134. nature.com/scitable/topicpage/gregor-mendel-and-the-principl
  2. Suza W, Lamkey K (eds). 2023. Quantitative Genetics for Plant Breeding. Iowa State University Digital Press. iastate.pressbooks.pub/quantitativegenetics/
  3. de Meijer EPM, Bagatta M, Carboni A, et al. 2003. The inheritance of chemical phenotype in Cannabis sativa L. Genetics 163(1):335-346. doi.org/10.1093/genetics/163.1.335
  4. Charlesworth D, Willis JH. 2009. The genetics of inbreeding depression. Nature Reviews Genetics 10:783-796. doi.org/10.1038/nrg2664
  5. Lynch RC, Vergara D, Tittes S, et al. 2016. Genomic and chemical diversity in Cannabis. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 35(5-6):349-363. doi.org/10.1080/07352689.2016.1265363

Was this helpful?

Tell us by joining the waitlist: Founding Members shape what the Professor writes next.

Professor Greenleaf

Grow with the Professor.

The GenetixBay community is coming: honest grow journals, permanent GB-IDs for genetics, and a Professor who answers with citations. Founding Members get first access and the lowest numbers in the archive.